Put-in-Bay Shopping

Whether you're looking for kitschy Put-in-Bay gear, fine gifts or just a souvenir to prove you were here, someone on the island sells it. Most shops are downtown on Delaware and Catawba Avenues.

Blue Cottage Gallery
The Blue Cottage Gallery is the island's only art gallery. Find artwork in all forms, including stained glass, pottery, oil, photography, watercolor, ceramics, jewelry, metal and glass - all by local and area artists. Looking at the art not enough for you? Every Saturday gives you the chance to meet artists and see them work their magic. You can also attend a class and try it out for yourself. Blue Cottage Gallery also carries the CDs of the local entertainers.
185 Toledo Ave. (419) 285-2128

The Candy Bar
The Candy Bar is the only bar on the island that doesn't sell beer - but it does sell chocolate, which makes it almost as good. or even better than other Put-in-Bay bars. Where else can you buy ¼ lb. per slice homemade fudge, salt water taffy and children's novelty candy? The Candy Bar is also known for dipping in chocolate anything it can get its hands on, like cookies, fresh fruit (ever had a chocolate covered grape or blueberry?) and pretzels.
Delaware Avenue

The Cuckoo's Nest
Shop at the Cuckoo's Nest and you'll swear you're in Key West instead of Ohio. Everything in the store has a tropical vibe to it, including dinnerware for boats or pools, artwork (the metal palm trees are a favorite), purses and beach bags, collectibles and women's clothing. Bath and body items are also available in this Caribbean-feel shop. Shipping and boat delivery available.
Catawba Avenue

The Country House
The Country House is a one-stop shop for anyone you're shopping for. Find gifts, souvenirs and decorations for all ages. Kids will love the toys, teens can check out the room decorations and adults can enjoy the selection of nautical, country and Victorian home accessories. There's even a section of the store dedicated to babies! The front porch is a great place to get deals on sale items.
Delaware Avenue

Del Sol
You might not believe it until you see it, but everything - everything - in Del Sol changes color in the sun, from nail polish to sunglasses to polos to board shorts to toys. This vibrant, colorful store also sells tote bags, T-shirts, tanks, watches, visors and hats and jewelry. A great store for summer fun. Located on the second floor of Harbor Village.
Harbor Village

Island Surf Shop
Just like it sounds, the Island Surf Shop has everything beach goers need, carrying bathing suits and board shorts for men and women, dresses, jewelry, purses and bags in Laguna brands like Roxy, Quicksilver, Oakley, Billabong, Reef and Rusty. The merchandise is trendy yet laidback, just like the island.
Catawba Avenue

Jessie's Jewelry
Jessie's Jewelry is where to go if you're looking for truly unique jewelry. Stop by for earrings, necklaces, pendants, pins and more made with hand-cut gemstones and wire crochet - all handmade by Jessie, who travels the world to get the biggest variety of stones. Don't miss her annual island-inspired pieces, including a tribute to the Mayfly and a model of Perry's Monument made with actual stone from the monument itself.
Bay View Avenue next to Wharfside

Lakeside Outfitters
Lakeside Outfitters is the only store on the island that carries high fashion names like Gucci, Armani, Dolce and Gabbana, Dior and Prada. Get trendy club gear or casual clothes for men and women, including shoes, sunglasses, bathing suits, accessories and dresses. Don't miss the 3 for $10 promotion, one of the best sales at Put-in-Bay.
Delaware Avenue

Looney Bin
Stop by the Looney Bin for entertainment novelty items that will be the hit of all your cocktail parties. Get the gear (don't miss the hand-painted Austrian wine glasses) and the beverages, sold at state minimum. Local wine from Pelee Island and Lonz Winery as well as fun brands like Ménage a Tois and Mommy's Time Out. Upscale, fun stuff for all budgets.
Catawba Avenue across from The Brewery

More For Kids
More For Kids is one store where you don't have to worry about telling the little ones "Don't touch that!" Here the clerks dress up in costumes and not only show you how the toys work, but encourage you to try them yourself. They also do a daily story time, giving parents and kids both a chance to relax for a bit. Bring the kids and let them have fun with arts and crafts, dress up, a reading corner, magician kits, action playsets and a puppet theater.
Catawba Avenue

Mr. Ed's Gift Shop
Don't miss the gift shop when you're at Mr. Ed's for a drink or a meal. Choose from a variety of styles, cuts and colors for men's and women's T-shirts and sweatshirts. Shirts feature the Mr. Ed's horse logo and/or the slogan "Nobody's Ugly After Two!" Located in the back corner of Mr. Ed's Bar and Grille across from the bar. Online ordering is available.
Delaware Avenue

The Shirt Shack
The Shirt Shack is the ultimate Put-in-Bay souvenir store - you can find all the necessities of island life here. Clothing includes bathing suits, Put-in-Bay sweatshirts, T-shirts, shorts and visors for the whole family. For hats, choose from baseball caps, straw hats, sombreros, fuzzy pimp hats or other silly things to put on your head. If you're looking for souvenirs to bring back, check out the key chains, magnets, shot glasses and leis. Don't miss the line of Corona bathing suits and clothes.
Delaware Avenue

Silly Goose
Silly Goose boasts the island favorite Wake Up Crabby Bloody Mary mix, sold individually or even by the case! Don't forget to pick up a Wind and Willow cheeseball or dessert mix to go along with the Bloody Mary's. Also for sale at Silly Goose are nostalgia games, Robeez slipper shoes for infants, local artwork, handmade decorations imported from Africa, candles and high-quality Put-in-Bay sweatshirts. Shipping and boat delivery available.
Catawba Avenue

South Bass Bessie's
Stop by South Bass Bessie's for gourmet food and spices like stuffed olives, Wake Up Crabby Bloody Mary Mix, pasta sauces and hot sauces. They also sell toddler clothing in sizes 2T-6 as well as upscale men's wear with a nautical vibe that fits right in with island life. Find T-shirts, polos, shorts, ties, belts and sweatshirts to look your best at the bay. Shipping and boat delivery available.
Harbor Village

Wharfside
Stopping at Wharfside is a must if fishing is on your island agenda - it's the only place on Put-in-Bay that sells fishing licenses and live bait, along with any other marine supplies you might need. But wait, there's more - if you need it, Wharfside's got it. They sell everything from gifts, to shampoo, to pots and pans. Stop by on your way out to pick up coffee, bakery, slushies or breakfast sandwiches. Ask about fish freezing or refrigerating.
Bay View Avenue near the Boardwalk

Web Design and Web Hosting Services by The Karcher Group